Lafayette Theatre

In 1916 The Lafayette Theatre and the Lafayette Players eventually came under the management of Levy and Quality Amusement Company. Levy abandoned the vaudeville and expanded the troupe to two permanent companies based in Harlem and Chicago and two traveling companies that toured the East Coast and the South. The Lafayette Players ultimately became one of the most respected African- American dramatic companies in the nation, known for reproducing Broadway plays and Shakespearean productions with all-black casts. Between 1916-1919 during Levy’s tenure at the theatre the Lafayette Players staged over a hundred serious dramatic works by both black and white writers.

Production List	Playwright	Opening Night	Year	White theater at the time of Lafayette of Production
In The Bishop's Carriage	Channing Pollack	17 July 1916	1907	Grand Opera House, NY
The Third Degree	Charles Klein	24 July 1916	1909	Hudson Theatre, NY
The Ghost Breaker	Paul Dickey Chas W. Goddard	31 July 1916	1913	Lyceum Theatre
A Pair of Sixes	Edward Henry Peples	8 October 1916	1914	Longacre Theatre
Big Jim Garrity	Owen Davis	17 August 1916	1914	New York Theatre
Sign of Four		17 August 1916	1903	West End Theatre
Stop Thief	Carlyle Moore	28 August 1916	1913	Gaiety Theatre
At Bay	George Scarborough	9 April 1916	1914	39th Street Theatre
Within the Law	Bayard Veiller	9 November 1916	1913 1928	Eltinge 42th Street Theatre Cosmopolitan Theatre.
Madame X	Alexander Bisson	18 September 1916	1920 1927	New Amsterdam Theatre Earl Carroll Theatre
The Family Cupboard	Owen Davis	2 October 1916	1915	Playhouse Theatre
The Conspiracy	Robert Baker John Emerson	9 October 1916	1914	New Amsterdam Theatre
The Lure	George Scarborough	16 October 1916	1913	Garrick Theatre
The Man of the Hour	George Broadhurst	23 October 1916	1906	Savoy Theatre
Forty-Five Minutes from Broadway	George Cohan	23 October 1916	1906	New Amsterdam Theatre New York Theatre George Cohan Theatre
The City	Clyde Fitch	13 November 1916	1910	Lyric Theatre Hackett Theatre Academy of Music Grand Opera Lyceum Theatre
The Lion and the Mouse	Charles Klein	20 November 1916	1905	Hudson Theatre Princess Theatre
Raffles	Eugene Prebre, E.W. Hornung	27 November 1916	1904 1910	Savoy Theatre Gaiety Theatre
Three Twins	Charles Dickens	12 April 1916	1908	Herald Square Theatre Majestic Theatre
Get Rich	Rich Wallingford George Cohan	12 November 1916	1910	Gaiety Theatre George M. Cohan Theatre
Trilby	Paul Potter adapted by DuMaurier	26 March 1917	1895 1905 1915 1921	Garden Theatre New Amsterdam Theatre Shubert Theatre National Theatre
The Yankee Prince	George Cohan	4 February 1917	1908	Knickerbocker Theatre
The Law of the Land	George Broadhurst	23 April 1917	1914	48@th Street Theatre
The Time, the Place, the Girl	Joseph E. Howard	30 April 1917	1907 1942	Wallack's Theatre Grand Opera Theatre Mansfield Theatre
Sinners	Owen Davis	5 July 1917	1915	Playhouse Theatre
The House of a Thousand Candles	George Middelton	21 May 1917	1908	Dalys Theatre
The Great Divide	William Vaughn Moody	28 May 1917	1907 1908 1917	Princess Theatre Daly's Theatre Academy of Music Theatre Grand Opera Theatre Lyceum Theatre
The Natural Law	Charles Sumner	6 April 1917	1915	Theatre Republic
Damaged Goods	Eugene Brieux	18 June 1917	1913	Fulton Theatre
The Yellow Ticket	Michael Morton	17 July 1917	1914	Eltinge 42nd Street Theatre
The Chocolate Soldier (American Version)	Stanislus Stange	23 July 1917
The Traffic	Rachael Marshall Oliver Bailey	30 July 1917	1914	New York Theatre
The Little Millionaire	George Cohan	8 June 1917	1912	George M. Cohan Theatre
Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde	Robert Louis Stevenson	1 August 1917	1887	New Amsterdam Theatre, NY
The Gamblers	Charles Klein	13 August 1917	1910	Maxine Elliot's Theatre
Charley's Aunt	Brandon Thomas	20 August 1917	1906	Manhattan Theatre
The Vampire	Lee Morrison Edgar Allan Woolf George Sylvester Viereck	27 August 1917
The Man from Mexico	H.A. Du Souchet	9 March 1917	1907	Hoyt's Theatre Garrick's Theatre
The Silent Witness	Jack Deleon Jack Celestine	9 October 1917	1916	Fulton Theatre
Are You A Mason?		17 September 1917	1901	Garrick Theatre Wallack's Theatre
The Inner Man		3 November 1918	1917	Lyric Theatre Cort Theatre
The Knife	Eugene Walters	18 March 1918	1917	Bijou Theatre
Faust	Adaptation from Faust by Johann Wolfgang von Goethe	4 January 1918	1930	Casino Theatre Centre Theatre
The Master Mind	David Carter	4 August 1918	1913	Harris Theatre
The Man Who Owns Broadway	George Cohan	15 April 1918	1910	New York Theatre
Sappho and Phaon	Percy MacKaye	22 April 1918	1907	Lyric Theatre
His Honor the Mayor	Charles Campbell	29 April 1918	1906	New York Theatre
Where do you Live?	Wallacks Alma George Hobart	13 May 1918	1911	Weber's Music Hall
Broken Threads	Ernest Wilkes	20 May 1918	1917	Fulton Theatre
Very Good Eddie	Guy Bolton	27 May 1918	1915	Princess Theatre Casino Theatre 39@th Street Theatre
The Blindness of Virtue	Cosmo Hamilton	24 June 1918	1912	39@th Street Theatre
A Butterfly on the Wheel?	Edward G. Hammerde F. Neilson K.C. Neilson	7 January 1918	1912	39@th Street Theatre
The Woman in the Case	Clyde Fitch	15 July 1918	1905	Herald Square Theatre
His Last Dollar	David Higgins Baldwin Cooke	22 July 1918	1904	American Theatre
The White Sister	Walter Hackett F. Marion Crawford	29 July 1918	1909	Daly's Theatre
The Boss	Edward Shelton	8 May 1918	1911	Astor Theatre
Cheating Cheater	Max Marcin	9 February 1918	1917	Eltinge 42@th Street Theatre
Arizona	Augustus Thoman	9 September 1918	1901 1912	Herald Square Theatre Lyric Theatre
The Rosary	Edward Rose	16 September 1918	1910	Garden Theatre
The Ninety and Nine	Ramsey Morris	20 January 1919	1903	Academy of Music
Man's Enemy	Eric Hudson Charles H. Langdon	2 October 1919	1900	Star Theatre 1913 Lyric Theatre
The Two Orphans	Eugene Cormon Adolphe D'Ennery	17 February 1919	1904 1874 1926	New Amsterdam Theatre Union Square Theatre Cosmopolitan Theatre
Convict 999	Walter Howard	3 March 1919	1907	Thelia Theatre
The Story of the Rosary	Owen Davis	3 October 1919	1914	Manhattan Opera House
The Guilty Man	Ruth Helen Davis Charles Klein	17 March 1919	1916	Astor Theatre
The Bridge	Rupert Hughes	4 July 1919	1909	Majestic Theatre
The Fortune Hunter	Winchell Smith	14 April 1919	1909	Gaiety Theatre
A Midnight Marriage	James Halleck Reid	21 April 1919	1904	Grand Opera House
The Burglar and the Lady	Langdon McCormick	5 May 1919	1906	American Theatre
The Havoc	H.S. Sheldon	26 May 1919	1911	Bijou Theatre
The Girl in the Taxi	Hugh Stainislus	6 February 1919	1910	Astor Theatre
Mrs. Temple's Telegram	Frank Wyatt	16 June 1919	1906	Hoyt Theatre
The Blue Envelope	Frank Hatch Robert Homans	6/23/19	1916	Cort Theatre